Somehow, he always manages to look comlpetely perfect. I can't even believe how great his smile is. And his eyes. And his hair. And Brad is also more quiet. He isn't very social; he never approaches people because he doesn't care about socialization. Being alone and being with other people seem to be the same to him, which I really envy (as I get very bored alone and I always think of something that I desperately need to tell someone). He does talk a lot, though, because people go up to him and start conversations all the time and once someone starts talking to him, he's a pretty active conversationalist.
Anyways, I think you should go for the new guy; he'd probably be a better boyfriend anyway and it sounds like you really like him.