Tuesday's Anti-LGBT hate crime, and the return of Kevin Jennings, I am out raged

TheInsideLlama's picture

A message from Executive Director Kevin Jennings

Friends,

As you may know, I returned to GLSEN following a five month sabbatical last week.

The below was not the kind of welcome back news I was hoping for.

Lawrence King was a self-identified gay student who attended Green Junior High in Oxnard, California. His feminine gender expression "was freaking the guys out" according to one of his classmates.

Apparently, for this, he had to die.

On Tuesday morning Lawrence was shot at point blank range in his eighth grade English class by a boy who had apparently been one of his anti-LGBT tormentors. Now he's going to die once they turn the machines off, which they may have already done by the time you get this message.

Ten years ago a gay college student, Matthew Shepard, was tied to a fence and beaten to death. Today, it's a gay junior high student being shot in the head. When will we, as a society, say enough is enough?

Kevin Jennings
Executive Director,GLSEN
90 Broad St., 2nd Fl., New York, NY 10004

http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-oxnard14feb14,0,7204301.story

Oxnard student declared brain dead

Lawrence King, 15, was shot and wounded at a junior high school Tuesday. A classmate faces murder charge.

By Catherine Saillant and Gregory W. Griggs

Los Angeles Times Staff Writers

February 13, 2008

An Oxnard junior high student who was shot in the head by a classmate earlier this week was declared brain dead Wednesday, and the 14-year-old male suspect now faces a first-degree murder charge, authorities said.

Lawrence King, 15, was declared brain dead by two neurosurgeons about 2 p.m. at St. John's Regional Medical Center in Oxnard, said Craig Stevens, senior deputy Ventura County medical examiner. King's body remains on a ventilator for possible organ donation, he said.

Authorities initially believed that King was improving following the shooting early Tuesday inside a classroom at E.O. Green Junior High School. But the boy's condition worsened early Wednesday, and he was placed on a ventilator a few hours later with his family nearby, said an official who asked not to be named.

David Keith, an Oxnard police spokesman, said the family would have no comment and asked the media to respect its privacy.

Police said the suspect, whose identity was not disclosed because of his age, shot King at least twice at the beginning of the school day and then fled the campus. The boy was apprehended by police a few blocks away and is being held in Juvenile Hall.

He is scheduled to appear in court today.

Dist. Atty. Gregory Totten said prosecutors would decide whether the case should remain in juvenile court after reviewing the police investigation. Under state law, prosecutors can ask the court to try the suspect as an adult, he said.

"In all probability he will be charged in adult court," Totten said.

Police have not determined a motive in the slaying but said it appeared to stem from a personal dispute between King and the suspect. Keith and Totten declined to elaborate. But several students at the south Oxnard campus said King and his alleged assailant had a falling out stemming from King's sexual orientation.

The teenager sometimes wore feminine clothing and makeup, and proclaimed he was gay, students said. Some of the male students were bothered by his appearance, calling it a distraction, several students said.

"He would come to school in high-heeled boots, makeup, jewelry and painted nails -- the whole thing," said Michael Sweeney, 13, an eighth-grader. "That was freaking the guys out."

Student Juan Sandoval, 14, said he shared a fourth-period algebra class with the suspect, whom he described as a calm, smart student who played on the basketball team.

"I didn't think he was that kind of kid," Sandoval said. "I guess you never know. He made a big mistake."

"Their lives are both destroyed now," said student Hansley Rivera, 12, after learning of King's death.

Several students said that a day before the shooting, King and several boys had some kind of altercation during the lunch period. Police and prosecutors said they had heard the same stories but have not come to a conclusion as to motive.

If the suspect targeted King because of his sexual orientation, it could rise to the level of a hate crime, authorities said.

"We've heard that and a lot of other things," Keith said. "But I can't say what the motive is until we finish our interviews."

Totten said he could not comment on the specifics of the case until he reviewed the police investigation. But a hate-crime enhancement is something that prosecutors would consider as they move forward, he said.

"It's something we will look at," he said. "But the case is going to be reviewed as a murder involving the use of a firearm, and that carries a potential sentence of 50 years to life."

Jerry Dannenberg, the school district superintendent, said E.O. Green staff were aware that King had butted heads with other students, including the suspect, and that they had offered both students help.

"They had been doing a lot of counseling and a lot of work with [King] to help him deal with some of his concerns and issues," Dannenberg said. "But I can't go into specifics about what was going on."

Bullying in schools has long been a problem. But recent studies show that a student who comes "out" as gay or lesbian is far more likely to suffer abuse than others, said Kevin Jennings, executive director of the Gay, Lesbian and Straight Education Network based in New York.

A student thought to be gay was five times as likely to be threatened or injured by a weapon, according to a 2002 California Department of Education study. Jennings said subsequent studies have found similar results.

His group advocates more teacher training on how to handle bullying and harassment, specifically bullying of gay students.

"This Oxnard shooting is very upsetting but not surprising," Jennings said. "The real issue is not the kid coming out, but the kid sitting next to him. Schools must teach that we may not like one another, but we must respect one another."

Teachers and counselors at E.O. Green Junior High, meanwhile, sought to calm fears about escalating violence at the south Oxnard campus. About a quarter of the school's 1,000 students stayed home Wednesday due to fear of reprisals, Dannenberg said.

He said the school will have extra staff and police on campus for the next few days. Counselors will also be on hand as long as needed, Dannenberg said. The school district will hold a meeting for parents next week to discuss concerns.

This week's shooting was a first, not only for the school but for all of Ventura County, which has never before seen a classroom fatality. Dannenberg said school administrators can take steps to keep guns out of schools but that nothing would ever work perfectly.

"It's not just the schools," he said. "We have a societal problem. Last week, it was gunfire at a City Council back east. And this week, unfortunately, it was us."

Comments

kaj's picture

It's so wierd and depressing

It's so wierd and depressing that an 8 year old in Colorado can get respected for being transgendered, and then something like this happens. Way too messed up.

jeff's picture

Hmm...

I like GLSEN, but they sort of show why I am wary of hate crimes legislation. They sort of turn everything around to be about a "self-identified gay student" whose "feminine gender expression" "was freaking the guys out."

The second paragraph? Oh, yeah, the kid is dead, btw.

To my knowledge, something being deemed a hate crime is only a factor in determining the length of a prison sentence, and I think making it the largest factor in the case sort of distracts from the more important aspect, namely the murder. If you don't try a good murder case, whether it was also a hate crime doesn't even come up.

---

"Be like a postage stamp. Stick to one thing until you get there." -- Josh Billings.

Add me on MySpace!

love__x's picture

this situation makes me so

this situation makes me so sad.